Yesterday, in a meeting in Lausanne, the FEI announced their decision that Rollkur and all other forms of aggressive riding is absolutely unacceptable and will be sanctioned from now on. They said specifically that Rollkur and hyperflexion IS aggressive riding and they said specifically that Rollkur is absolutely unacceptable.
Like most of the horse world, I was cheering and excited. So why was I only ecstatic for a short time? First of all, a friend pointed out that we’ve been at this name change place before, where the FEI just changed the name from rollkur to hyperflexion, and defused the outrage but changed nothing at all for the horses.
So we are yet to see whether using the words Low Deep and Round will change anything at all for the horses either – or whether it is just a politically astute way to defuse everyone’s outrage.
Then I realised that something incredibly important was missing from that announcement and because of the missing element, I realised that the FEI has only swept the problem of systematic horse abuse in training under the rug and out of the public eye.
The FEI did not say a word about changing the way that they judge a dressage test.
They have the ability to change systematic abuse of horses in training for dressage and they didn’t do it.
The outrage over the blue tongued horse video happened because what was considered normal in training at home, was filmed in public and posted in public all over the world.
Now is that good enough for you? Are you happy for the blue tongued horse to be blue tongued at home out of your sight? Is out of sight, out of mind OK by you?
“Goodness me, how can you change what happens out of the public eye?” you ask. Well if that thought didn’t cross your mind, I’m going to tell you anyway…
Right now, in dressage, the FEI controlled judges award high competition test scores to horses who move their legs extravagantly but who are not in collection and in fact, cannot even walk properly any more because of the systematic muscular–skeletal damage caused by the training methods that are used both at home and warming up for a competition.
And the FEI didn’t change that. They made absolutely no mention at all of changing the method of judging, bringing the judging back into line with their own rulebook.
So the reality is, that while they reward crippled horses who can no longer walk, with high scores, and horses who have extravagant leg movement but are no longer physically able to hold real collection for longer than moments at a time, then the FEI are rewarding the systematic abuse of horses, even if most of the people using this technique don’t even realise how abusive it really is.
The abuse just won’t happen so publicly any more.
I don’t know about you, but at this reality I got all depressed. So what can we do to change that systematic abuse of horses in dressage then?
So here’s the big deal, folks - the anti-rollkur campaign needs to die.
Don’t have a fit, I am not suggesting that we give up. Not in the slightest. I believe that there are times when we have to get passionate about what we DON’T want, in order to change to what we DO want.
The trouble is, the very nature of the anti-rollkur campaign makes the people who are using rollkur defensive. And defensive people rarely change the way that you want them to change.
The “anti” nature of the rollkur horse abuse campaign has served its purpose in identifying very clearly for more than 41,000 people, in just a few weeks, what we DON’T want. So now it’s time to identify what we DO want and work towards that in an exciting and much more powerful way.
Being “anti” something is not a useful way to change things. Just like in our work with our horses, when we fight something, whether we “win” or “lose”, we are creating a resistance somewhere else. In our horse training, when we resist our horse, we simply create a new problem that pops up somewhere else.
Everywhere in horses and in life generally, when we resist something, when we fight something, when we are “anti” something – then we simply create a new problem that pops up somewhere else.
Well guess what, folks, in the midst of all that reality that we’ve just been exposed to, I have some seriously good news – good news that has completely lifted up my spirits and I hope it lifts up your spirits too.
Just like we can do it differently with our horses, we can do it differently here and make it possible for a world-wide movement of beautiful dressage to blossom – beautiful dressage that we DO want to see.
A bunch of amazing people are working behind the scenes – right now, as I write this article – to bring you an exciting and incredibly positive project that will help us bring about the changes that we would like to see in dressage or in the horse world generally.
Instead of focussing on what we “don’t want”, this project will be about focussing on what we DO want – focussing on what inspires us, focussing on our own personal ideas of the beauty that horses and people can be together.
41,000 people, in just a few weeks of action, signed the petition that went to the FEI to change rollkur. So in the midst of the reality of the decision made in Lausanne, use the power of what you DON’T want, to think about what it will be like to have more than 41,000 people working in a positive way to spread the beauty of what dressage can be.
Wow, what a thought…
So watch this space!!!!
Article by Jenny Pearce and published in Horses For Life magazine Feb 2010.